|
Back
A Prospective Documentation of the Results of Acupuncture and Homeopathy
Principal Investigators: C. Güthlin, Dipl. Psych.; H. Walach, PhD
Affiliations: University Hospital Freiburg, Department of Environmental Medicine
and Hospital Epidemiology, Germany
Background: A German health insurance company, the Innungskrankenkasse (IKK),
launched a test phase for acupuncture and homeopathy in three German federal
states (Baden-Württemberg, Sachsen, Sachsen-Anhalt). The aim of the evaluation
is to document effects, costs, usefulness and patient satisfaction for a medical
treatment not fully incorporated in the German social law.
Method: Prospective documentation of all patients insured with the IKK provided
with free treatment of acupuncture and homeopathy. 5000 patients have been
treated by acupuncture and 1000 patients by homeopathy. All patients have been
followed-up from the beginning of treatment for four years according to
intent-to-treat. Doctors provide data on each visit (diagnoses, treatment,
change of symptoms), and patients complete questionnaires at the beginning and
at the end of treatment, as well as each year after the end of the treatment
(complaints, current treatment, general health status as measured by the MOS
SF-36). Insurance data on work-days lost have been provided by the insurance
company.
Results: The physicians ratings of the change of the main diagnosis showed
improvement of one point on a 7-point-scale (SD=0.5). These results are
vindicated by the patients follow-up questionnaire: Approximately 80% of the
patients rated the therapy as at least partially effective. Quality of life, as
measured by the MOS SF-36, improved in most dimensions to a highly significant
degree and remained stable over the observed time period.
Conclusions: Change can be observed within a clinically significant range. About
80% of the patients reported some sort of improvement as reflected by their
doctors ratings and the quality of life measures.
|