|
Back
Investigation of
the Zwitterion Water Structure Hypothesis in Homeopathy
Principal Investigator: David J. Anick, PhD,
MD, Psychiatrist and Homeopath, Marino Center for Progressive Health
Affiliations: McLean Hospital; Harvard
Medical School
Background: Homeopathic remedies of high
dilution may contain no molecules of the original substance. One
postulated explanation for their clinical effectiveness is that
information is imprinted in the liquid water during the processes of
dilution and succession, and this occurs through the presence of
specialized clusters of quasi-stable water molecules called zwitterions.
The Zwitterion Hypothesis states that homeopathic remedies made in water
are weak aqueous solutions of certain species of zwitterions with
exceptionally stable properties.
Hypotheses: 1) To demonstrate the existence
of stable water clusters known as zwitterions detectable at room
temperature for over several hours; 2) to identify and test properties of
zwitterions using computational chemistry; and 3) to investigate, using
NMR spectroscopy, whether solutions of chemically identical water display
different NMR spectra explainable by the presence of low concentrations of
stable or quasi-stable zwitterions and if they are present in homeopathic
models.
Materials and Methods: The use of
commercially available computational chemistry programs that do
quantum-based modeling to predict optimal geometries for zwitterions, and
also the reaction pathways and energy barriers involved in destabilizing
or neutralizing them. Proton nuclear magnetic resonance measurements will
be used to detect the presence of homeopathic remedies, zwitterions or
other stable clusters.
Anticipated results: Measurable differences
in NMR spectra could account for the differential activity of homeopathic
remedies, and will identify a new way to think about how clinically
relevant information can be transmitted in the absence of chemical
activators.
Relationship to SIIB mission and healing:
This research could provide a physical description (NMR signature) to
differentiate homeopathic remedies from ordinary water. Evidence of an
information signal mechanism of action would bolster the scientific rigor
and reproducibility of homeopathic studies, and could serve to set quality
control standards for homeopathic products. Potential outcomes include a
scientific conference to explore information signals in homeopathy, a core
laboratory for quality control of homeopathic products, and intellectual
property related to the measurement of quality standards.
|