Back

Guidelines for Developing Working Papers for the Samueli Conference on Definitions and Standards in Healing Research

{DRAFT 1 July 2002}

Larry Dossey, MD, Marilyn Schlitz PhD, Janet Quinn PhD, RN,
William Miller MD, Sarah Warber MD, Jeffrey Dusek PhD,
Ronald Chez MD, Wayne B Jonas MD

An emphasis on healing and healing relationships has been integral to all cultures since the dawn of mankind.  Three features of healing present throughout most traditions are the intention and focus of the participants, the energy exchanged among them and the relationship developed between healer and healee.

 We believe major difficulties in moving forward in these fields of scientific inquiry are 1] the lack of standard definitions of these features and other terms, and 2] the current research is often of poor quality with unclear goals and inadequate design, measurement and analysis. The creation of clear and standard definitions and guidelines for research methodologies in healing will allow a rational and systematic research agenda to develop.

 The roles of the writing committees for the conference on Definitions and Standards in Healing Research are A] to clarify the meaning of terms used in these fields, and B] to provide methodology and protocol guidelines for doing quality research. The chairs of these writing committees discussed the following working definitions as to the meaning of terms in healing research. Accordingly, we offer them as a starting point for beginning the discussion and the development of the working papers on healing research.

 This effort at definitions continues to be a work in progress, and we anticipate additional edits as the committee create their drafts. Larry Dossey is the Chair of this group. Correspondence should be directed to him with a copy to Ron Chez. Ron will incorporate and distribute changes as they are agreed upon.

A. Working definitions and terms:

1.   Consciousness:  The capacity to react to, attend to, and be aware of self and other.  Consciousness subsumes all categories of experience, including perception, cognition, intuition, instinct, will and emotion, at all levels, including those commonly termed “conscious,” “subconscious,” “superconscious,” or “unconscious,” “intention,” and “attention,” without presumption of specific psychological or physiological mechanisms. Neither consciousness nor its environment exists in isolation; they can be represented only in interaction and exchange of information (Jahn and Dunne, 1987). 

2.   Curing:  the resolution or eradication of a diagnosis or a disease .  

3.   Energy:   A physical force, of which four types are recognized in physics — the electromagnetic, the gravitational, and the strong and weak nuclear forces -- all of which are detectable with proper instrumentation, and all of which diminish with increasing spatial separation.  Bioenergy is a force or influence believed or hypothesized to flow through and off of living systems.  Eastern concepts such as qi, ki, or prana; ancient European concepts such as mana, pneuma, or vital force; and more recent Western concepts such as bion, orgone, or paraelectricity, are examples (Benor, 2001).  The word “biofield” has been proposed and used by some as an additional term for bioenergy. The popular notion of energy as simply “the capacity to do work” may be a bridging concept for these two terms.  

4.   Environment:  the context or habitat within which all living systems participate and interact including the physical body and its physical habitat, and cultural, psychological, social, and historical influences. 

5.   Healing: those physical, mental, social  and spiritual processes of recovery, repair, renewal and transformation that increase order, coherence and wholeness.  Healing is an emergent process of the whole system, and may or may not involve curing.    

6.   Healing intentionality:  The effort by one or more persons to improve the health status of another person through conscious, purposeful actions.  

7.   Non-local (or Distant) healing: A hypothesized form of healing consciousness occurring beyond the reach of the physical senses and that appear unmediated by any demonstrable form of physical energy (Dossey, 1993).    

8.   Holistic healing:  a form of healing based on attention to all aspects of an individual — physical, mental, social and spiritual.   

9.   Healing relationships:  the quality and characteristics of interactions between healer and healee that facilitate healing. Characteristics of this interaction involve empathy, caring, love, warmth, trust, confidence, credibility, honesty, expectation, courtesy, respect, and communication.  The effects of these characteristics may be mediated locally via the physical senses or may occur nonlocally. 

10. Information:  any array of stimuli to which consciousness or its environment is capable of sensing and reacting (Jahn and Dunne, 1987). 

11. Intention:  The conscious determination to do a specific thing or to act in a specific manner. 

12. Attention: Awareness and focus of conscious awareness on an object, experience, sensation or process. 

13. Nonlocality:   Generally:  the state of being unconfined and unrestricted to a particular place.  In modern physics:  a fundamental property of the universe, in which entities once in contact demonstrate correlated behaviors, instantly and to the same degree, regardless of the extent of spatial separation (Nadeau and Kafatos, 1999).   Nonlocal events are unconstrained by lightspeed and have three defining characteristics: they are unmediated, unmitigated, and immediate (Herbert 1987, 1993). Operationally, non-local events are said to occur when they appear to be unmediated by any demonstrable form of physical energy. 

[Nonlocal mind:  a hypothesized manifestation of consciousness in which space and time are transcended.   Explanatory connections with quantum-physical nonlocality may or may not exist and are not implied.] 

14. Prayer:  Communication with an Absolute-immanent-transcendent spiritual force, however named.  Such communication may take a variety of forms and may be theistic or nontheistic in nature, as in some forms of Buddhism.    

15. Intercessory prayer:  Appeal to an Absolute-immanent-transcendent  spiritual force to influence another person, thing or event.   

16. Healing prayer:  Appeal to an Absolute-immanent-transcendent spiritual force for healing and recovery of self or other.    

17. Directed prayer:  prayer that is offered with a specific outcome in mind.    

18. Nondirected prayer:  prayer that is offered with no specific outcome in mind, such as “Thy will be done” or “May the best outcome prevail” (Dossey, 1993). 

19. Religion:  the codified and ritualized behaviors of those involved in spirituality. 

20. Spirituality:  the feelings, thoughts, experiences, and behaviors that arise from a search for the sacred.  Spirituality is generally, though not universally, considered to involve a sense of connection with the Absolute-imminent-transcendent spiritual force, however named, as well as the conviction that meaning, value, direction, and purpose are valid aspects of the universe.  

21. Transpersonal:  beyond the physical body of an individual. 

22. Transpersonal psychology:  A system of personal understanding that  “is …based on people’s experiences of temporarily transcending our usual identification with our limited biological, historical, cultural and personal self and, at the deepest and most profound levels of experience possible, recognizing/becoming ‘something’ of vast intelligence and compassion that encompasses/is the entire universe.  From this perspective our ordinary, ‘normal’ biological, historical, cultural and personal self is seen as an important, but quite partial (and often pathologically distorted) manifestation or expression of this much greater ‘something’ that is our deeper origin and destination” (Tart, 2002).

B. Research goals-design match

The definition of quality research depends on the goals of that research.  Therefore, a clear selection of research goals and questions is required first.  Quality guidelines for research should accomplish both general and specific goals. In these working papers we are looking for quality guidelines for research on healing that involve the following:

1. Proof of causality: Sometimes also called “proof of principle” research. this requires careful control of all parameters that might influence the outcome other than the purported causal influence.  It also usually requires exact, independent replication and may require systematic negative controls. Examples of this include research on mind-matter interactions (MMI) with random event generators and DMILS experiments with EDA outcome parameters.

2. Demonstration of theory/mechanism:  This involves the selection of specific and sometimes multiple control situations to test a theory or mechanisms. Examples include testing of the data augmentation theory (DAT) in MMI research or the mechanism of intracellular calcium rise from bioenergy. The controls will vary as a function of theory.

3. Clinical Efficacy: This research is directed at whether causal principles apply to a healing intervention for a specific outcome. This usually requires a double blind, randomized controlled trial with a detailed specification of both the intervention and the primary outcome to be changed. The CONSORT criteria for reporting clinical research (especially the internal validity criteria) are a good starting point for this. (Rennie, 2001)

4. Clinical Effectiveness: These studies are designed to examine the contribution of a healing intervention to outcomes in non-experimental clinical setting. Also known as observational or outcomes studies they are often part of health services research. External validity criteria are useful guidelines for determining quality research on clinical effectiveness.

5. Impact Studies: Sometimes term “pragmatic trials”, they are designed to assess the impact (in terms of feasibility, quality of life, clinical outcomes, economic burden and human relationship parameters). They assess the impact of intervention by a whole system, usually in an unblinded, but randomized fashion using standard care as the baseline control. In terms of quality criteria, they attempt to maximize external validity and fall midway between efficacy and effectiveness studies on internal validity. (Lewith, Jonas and Walach, 2001)

C. Example criteria:

The following is a set of research quality items called the Likelihood of Validity Evaluation (LOVE) used in complementary medicine research; it may be of value to the writing groups (Jonas and Linde, 2001). A more detailed set of quality evaluation criteria for studies of “clinical efficacy” and “laboratory research” are available.

 THE LIKELIHOOD OF VALIDITY EVALUATION GUIDELINES

 

DIMENSION
 

MAIN CRITERIA

Internal Validity

How likely is it that the effects reported
are due to the independent variable
(the treatment)?

Randomization
(Was subject assignment to treatment groups done randomly and in a concealed manner?)
Baseline comparability
(Where gender, age, and prognostic factors balanced?)
Change of intervention
(Was there loss to follow-up, contamination, poor compliance?)
Blinding
(Did the patients, practitioners, evaluators, analysts know who got the treatment?)
Outcomes
(Was the objectivity, reliability, and sensitivity of the outcome assessed?)
Analysis
(Was the number treated large? Where p. values significant?
Was there multiple outcomes measured and analyzed?)

 

External Validity

How likely is it that the observed effects
would occur outside the study and in
different settings?

Generalizability
(Was there a range of patients as they would be seen in practice or where there multiple or narrow inclusions and exclusions?
Was the study done at several sites with similar results?)
Reproducibility
(Was what was done clear?
Where Confidence Intervals reported?
Was the treatment transferable to other practitioners?)
Clinical Significance
(Was the effect size big enough to make a difference?
Is the condition in need of this type of treatment?
Were any preferences determined?
Was adherence good?)
Therapeutic Interference
(Was there flexibility in varying the treatment?
Was feedback on the outcomes available?
Is the treatment feasible in most (or your) practice settings?)\
Outcomes
(Were the outcomes clinically relevant?
Were the outcomes checked for importance with the patients?
Were any important outcomes missing?)

 

Model Validity

How likely is it that the study accurately
reflects the system under investigation?

Representativeness/accuracy
(Were the therapists well trained and
experienced?
Was the treatment strategy adequate?
Was the treatment clearly described?)
Informed consent
(Was the informed consent
comprehensive?
Was it effective - did patients understand it?)
Did it generate expectations different from practice?)
Methodology matching
(Were the goals of the study clear and
limited?
Did the investigators select the correct research
Method to achieve the goals? see
citation categories)
Model congruity
(Were the patients classified, was
the treatment determined and were the outcomes assessed according to the system of the
practice being assessed? )
Context/Meaning
(Did the patients/practitioners believe
in the therapy?
How well was the intervention adapted
to the culture, family, meaning of the
patient?)

 

Reporting Quality

How likely is it that the report accurately
reflects what was found in the study?
How clear and accurate is the
information presented?

Comprehensive
(Can you address the above criteria?)
Clarity
(Could you reproduce this study?)
Conclusions
(Were the conclusions and reporting format
(e.g., relative vs  absolute improvement rates, strength of wording) appropriate to the data collected ?)

 

Sources (healing):

Benor DJ.   Spiritual Healing.   Southfield, MI:  Vision; 2002.

Chalmers DJ. The puzzle of conscious experience.  Scientific American . 1995; 273(6): 80-86.

Clarke CJS.  The nonlocality of mind.  Journal of Consciousness Studies.  1995;2(3):231-40.

Dossey L.  Recovering the Soul.  San Francisco, CA:  HarperSanFrancisco; 1987.

Dossey L.   Healing Words.   San Francisco, CA:  HarperSanFrancisco; 1993.

Herbert N.  Quantum Reality.  Garden City, NY:  Anchor/Doubleday; 1987.

Herbert N.  Elemental Mind.   New York, NY:  Dutton;1993.

Jahn RG, Dunne BJ.    Margins of Reality:  The Role of Consciousness in the Physical World .  New York:  Harcourt Brace Jovanovich; 1987.

Jahn RG, Dunne BJ. A modular model of mind/matter manifestations (M5).  Journal of Scientific Exploration.  2001;15(3):299-329.

Nadeau R, Kafatos M.  The Non-Local Universe:  The New Physics and Matters of the Mind.  New York, NY:  Oxford University Press; 1999.

Radin D.  The Conscious Universe.  San Francisco:  HarperSanFrancisco, 1997.

Rauscher EA, Targ R.  The speed of thought:  Investigation of a complex space-time metric to describe psychic phenomena.  Journal of Scientific Exploration.  2001;15(3):331-354.

Tart CT.  Parapsychology and transpersonal psychology. Journal of Parapsychology. 2002:66(1):31-47.

Walach, Harald.  Theory and apory in healing research:  “Influence” versus “correlational” models.  Sutble Energies & Energy Medicine.  2002; 11(3): 189-205. 

Sources (research methods):

Jonas, W.B. and Linde, K. Conducting and Evaluating Clinical Research in Complementary and Alternative Medicine. In Principles and Practice of Clinical Research. Gallin, J. (ed.). New York: Academic Press. 2002 (in press)

Lewith, G.L., Jonas, W.B., Walach, H., (eds.) Clinical Research Methods in Complementary Medicine. London: Hartcourt Health Sciences. 2002.

Rennie, D. “CONSORT revised: Improving the reporting of randomized trials.” JAMA. 2001; 285(15): 2006-2007.

 

 





Funded Research