Distant Mental Interaction with Living Systems: A Critical Assessment and

Re-Testing

Principal Investigator: Stefan Schmidt, PhD.

Affiliations: University Hospital Freiburg, Department of Environmental Medicine and Hospital Epidemiology

Background: In a summary meta-analysis of research called Direct Mental Interaction with Living Systems (DMILS), a highly significant effect of medium size from a set of studies was found. This finding indicates that two physically isolated persons may interact without using conventional means of communication, i.e. one person seems to be able to mentally “influence” the physiological arousal of another person (the measurement used was electrodermal activity).

Objective of the study: The aim of this project was to assess this claim with different and more rigorous research strategies. This included a more careful meta-analysis and two experiments using more stringent control methods than in the past.

Method and Results: Two persons are separated in two different rooms which are ideally electromagnetically and acoustically shielded.  One person, the receiver, is asked to rest in a relaxed, but awake state for the next 20 to 30 minutes while his or her electrodermal activity (EDA), and indicator of autonomous nervous system activity, is continuously monitored.  The other person, the sender, is asked at the same time either to activate or to calm the "receiver" by an intentional effort that is not further specified.  Calm and activate epochs are presented in a randomized and balanced order and last usually 30 to 60 seconds.  The session is evaluated by comparing the EDA activity during calm and activate epochs.  If there is a difference, and any other conventional information transfer can be excluded, this reflects a distant intention effect.  This experiment is designed amongst others to assess the basic mechanism behind any distant healing effort.  There is a similar experimental paradigm by the name "Remote Staring" where the first person (observee) can be watched by the second one (observer) through a closed circuit television system.  Within this project an extensive review of all these studies was conducted.  All available published and unpublished material was collected and rated on various dimensions of quality.  Finally a meta-analytical integration of all data was conducted.  The overall results show a small, but highly significant effect for both paradigms.  Higher quality studies show smaller effects.  The complete data base on which this analysis is based reflects data from almost 1400 sessions.

 

Reference: Schmidt S, Schneider R, Utts J, Walach H.  Distant intentionality and the feeling of being stared at: Two meta-analyses.  British Journal of Psychology 95:235-247, 2004.


Copyright © 2004 Samueli Institute, Inc. All rights reserved.
The Samueli Institute conducts research on the science of healing.