

A Double-blind Randomized Homeopathic Remedy Proving with Healthy Individuals: Comparison of Two High Potencies (C30)
Principal Investigators: H. Möllinger, MD; H. Walach, PhD
Affiliations: Gesundheitszentrum Sokrates, Güttingen, Switzerland; University Hospital Freiburg, Department of Environmental Medicine and Hospital Epidemiology
Background: According to homeopathic theory, symptoms provoked by the homeopathic remedy in a pathogenetic trial (PT) make up the remedy picture serving as the basis for the homeopathic treatment. Little is known whether the symptoms produced by the remedy differ from symptoms produced by placebo. This is because both homeopathic remedy and placebo can produce so called unspecific effects due to psychological reasons. We therefore explore the distinctiveness of homeopathic symptoms and placebo symptoms.
Objective of the study: To compare two homeopathic high potencies which previously have not been thoroughly tested, but which may more readily differ in their symptoms when compared to each other than when compared with placebo.
Methods: This is a three-armed, randomized prospective, blinded pilot study in which a blinded materia medica expert identified symptoms with regard to their number and specificity. Twenty-one healthy homeopathic practitioners noted symptoms produced after remedy intake by patients who were randomly assigned to receive either (1) Calendula officinalis, (2) Ferrum muriaticum, or (3) placebo. After a seven day baseline symptoms recording period, proving substances were taken until symptoms occur. In daily supervision phone calls, symptoms were verified by the supervisor. The main outcome measure is the total number of symptoms produced and number of specific symptoms produced.
Results: The results showed that both remedies "produced" significantly more symptoms than placebo. With regard to the specificity, the Calendula officinalis group displayed more remedy specific symptoms than placebo. However, in the Ferrum muriaticim group more Calendula symptoms than placebo were recorded.
Relationship to SIIB Mission and Healing: Homeopathy has suffered from a dearth of solidly constructed scientific studies in provings which consist of randomization and double blinding. This research will contribute to a more thorough and rigorous analysis of the proving process.
Reference: Möllinger H, Schneider R, Löffel M, Walach H (in press). A double-blind, randomized, homeopathic remedy proving with healthy individuals: Comparison of two high potencies. Forschende Komplementärmedizin und Klassische Naturheilkunde 2004.