Consciousness and Healing Review Program

Principal Investigators: Cindy C. Crawford, BA; Andrew G. Sparber, RN; Wayne B. Jonas, MD

Affiliations: Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences, Samueli Institute for Information Biology, and Patient Care Services, Clinical Center, National Institute of Health, Bethesda, MD

Background: If there is more to healing than belief, such effects should be able to be isolated by appropriate methods such as randomization, blinding and control conditions.  Collectively, these are called internal validity and reflect the quality of clinical and experimental research.  Systematically evaluating the internal validity of research on healing can help determine whether its claims are more than belief.  Systematic reviews of published research are also an important step in bringing about a consensus of thought in an area of study.

Objective of the Study:
To systematically review the quality of all published experimental clinical and laboratory research involving hands-on and distant healing.

Methods and Design: All published randomized, controlled trials of spiritual healing (hands on healing and distance healing) done in clinical and laboratory settings from their inception to present were collected and systematically evaluated for the scientific quality using pre-defined methodological criteria..

Results: Distant healing studies scored better than hands-on healing studies and laboratory studies better than clinical studies.  Many studies of healing contained major problems that must be addressed in any future research .

Publication:
Crawford, C.C., Sparber, A.G., Jonas, W.B.  A systematic review of the quality of research on hands-on and distance healing:  Clinical and laboratory studies.  A supplement to Altern Ther Health Med. 2003; 9(3): A96-A104.

 

PDF Link


Copyright © 2004 Samueli Institute, Inc. All rights reserved.
The Samueli Institute conducts research on the science of healing.