Concept Proposal Review Process

Concept Proposal Review Process and 2006 Review Dates

 

Concept proposals are reviewed quarterly by the Institute’s Scientific Evaluation Committee (SEC).  The deadline for submission of concept proposals is two weeks before the review date.  Proposals that are received after the deadline are held until the next review date.  Applicants are typically notified of the results of the review within three weeks of the review date. 

 

Review date

Deadline for submissions

Notification date

April 17

April 10

April 28

May 22

May 8

June 12

July 12

June 28

August 2

October 20

October 6

November 10

 

Concept Proposal Review Criteria

 

Concept proposals are evaluated by a primary and secondary reviewer, as well as by other members of the Scientific Evaluation Committee.  All proposals are given a Priority Score and a Readiness Score. 

 

The Priority Score encompasses factors such as:

·       Compatibility with SIIB research domains and priorities (insert link to new research domains page),

·       Public health and clinical importance of the scientific area to be addressed

·       Cohesiveness of aims, background, rationale, conceptual framework and proposed methods

·       Level of innovation of concepts and approaches

·       Likelihood that anticipated results could be published in a peer-reviewed journal

 

The Readiness Score encompasses factors such as:

·       Rigor and appropriateness of design, setting, population or model, intervention or dependent variable, controls, outcomes and measures

·       Feasibility of the proposed project timeframe

·       Identification of potential difficulties and alternatives,

·       Qualifications, capabilities and experience of the investigators

·       Institutional resources, infrastructure and support